About — BluCat Consulting
About · Scott Arena

“I need your help.”

The shortest version of what this business actually is fits inside one phone call I nearly did not answer.

Before BluCat

The first one I ever built, I built for myself.

Years before I started BluCat, I worked for a nonprofit. Part of my job was entering the previous day’s sales into QuickBooks Online. Every charge came through Stripe. Every one had to be found, matched to a customer, coded to the right program, entered, and the processing fee recorded separately. Every morning, before anything else. Two hours, every day.

So I built something. A course database mapped each course number to the right QuickBooks product and class, and Zapier did the rest — found or created the customer, recorded the sale against the correct program, and booked the Stripe fee as its own expense.

Two hours every morning became none. And the program reports got better than they’d ever been, because a machine codes consistently and a person at 7am doesn’t.

I wasn’t a consultant. I was the guy doing the data entry, and I got tired of it.

The best automations don’t come from someone who knows the software. They come from someone who has actually done the task and knows exactly which part of it is stupid.

Read the case study →

The phone rang with a name I hadn’t seen in years.

We’d worked together at another company a long time ago, and we hadn’t stayed in touch — the kind of contact you assume you’ll never hear from again. I looked at the screen and thought about letting it go to voicemail.

I answered.

“I need your help.”

“What’s going on?”

“I’m on the board of a nonprofit. Their books are in really bad shape. We need you to fix them.”

It was a school in Florida. Their books were, in fact, in bad shape — and I wasn’t the first person they’d asked. They’d already brought in other people to clean it up, and it hadn’t gotten done.

That’s more common than you’d think. Cleanup work looks like data entry from the outside, so organizations hire for data entry, and then the project stalls partway through because nobody can figure out how the file got that way in the first place.

We fixed it. Not just the numbers — the processes underneath, so it wouldn’t drift back. Then I trained their new bookkeeper to run it.

That was three years ago. I still consult with them on the complicated things.

That call is the shortest version of what this business actually is. Somebody is in trouble with their books, they’ve usually tried something already, and they need someone who will see it all the way through instead of leaving halfway.

I’m glad I picked up.

Read the full case study →

How we work

Four things we will not do.

Sell you an automation you do not need

One client’s POS integration works fine at their volume. We left it running and said so.

Quote a cleanup before seeing the file

The work is proportional to how the damage happened, not to how many transactions there are.

Promise full automation of a partial job

If the source data does not contain what the task needs, a person still has to do that part. We say which part.

Leave halfway

Every cleanup ends with the process rebuilt — and we run it, or we train you or your staff to run it.

An unusual background

Staying steady when someone else isn’t.

Before this, I spent seven years living and studying at a yoga institute. It’s an unusual background for a bookkeeper, and it’s the most useful training I have.

Finances make people anxious, and anxious people get defensive, avoid the conversation, or dig in. Being able to stay steady when someone else isn’t — and to understand what’s actually driving how they’re reacting — is most of what makes the hard conversations work.

Scott Arena and his wife Scott Arena and his wife in Rome

Scott, off the clock with his beautiful wife Heather. Left: Illinois. Right: Rome, Italy.

Where we are

Saint Joseph, Michigan — and wherever the file is.

We work in person across Southwest Michigan and remotely nationwide. Sitting on the Michigan–Indiana line means multi-state payroll — including Indiana county income taxes — is routine here rather than an exception.

615 Broad Street, Suite 207
Saint Joseph, MI 49085
+1-269-281-4499
The thesis, in one line

Data gets entered once, at its source, and everything downstream is generated from it.

It is why a POS reconciliation, a contractor’s job costing, a nonprofit’s bill run and an Airtable build all turn out to be the same project underneath.

Suites 206 and 207
Suites 206 and 207, top of the stairs.
Conference room
Where discovery calls happen in person.
Office hallway
Between the two suites.

Meet the rest of the team

See the team